Voters Reject Apache Elementary School District Failing Status Quo

APACHE ELEMENTARY USDVotes
GROSSMAN, WILLIAM A.38
KRENTZ, FRANK R.29
Total Votes67

Voters in the Apache Elementary School District rejected the failing status quo in the 2016 General Election when they elected William “Billy” Grossman to the governing board. The district, one of the oldest in the state, has been in turmoil in recent years.

Governing board member Frank Krentz, who represented the old guard, was defeated by Mr. Grossman due in part for his failure to hear the voices of area residents.

The well-respected Krentz family has been an integral part of keeping the one classroom school district going for years. However, under the leadership of teacher/principal/superintendent Ms. Palma Hudson, the once thriving school now has only two students and three employees.

The alleged mistreatment of students, parents, and taxpayers by Hudson, with the tacit approval of Krentz and his uncle, governing board President Bill Kimble, has forced families to take their children elsewhere.

Related article: Apache School District Spins Out Of Locals’ Control

Mr. Grossman, who has lived in the area mere two decades, is widely seen as a representative of change and accountability.

Community leader and area rancher Ed Ashurst said of the change on the board, “This is a classic example of the voters being tired of dysfunctional government.”

Krentz, whose own family has been devastated by flawed government policies, has relied on guidance from the quasi-government Arizona School Board Association. The Association trains school board members to serve the needs of administrators rather than the needs and demands of constituents. As a result, when asked to intervene on behalf of community members, Krentz wrongly claimed that the board did not have the authority to have flexibility in administering policy. As the ADI reported early this year, Krentz’s lack of compassion for the residents stunned even his most ardent supporters.

Did you know?

DistrictNacoMcNealBisbeePearceApache
Spending by Area20152015201520152015
Percent in Classroom55.3%43.4%49.6%55.0%50.4%
Instruction4,4546,7624,7967,12017,272
Administration1,1983,4311,5242,3236,682
Plant operations1,0642,1901,5462,0414,271
Food service6461,0903735260
Transportation2851,0144764263,489
Student support1706635893322,455
Instruction support230432356187122
Total operational8,04715,5829,66012,95534,291
Land and buildings0223960255
Equipment281,0383622701,994
Interest055038
Other00900
Total nonoperational281,3163803332,257
Total per pupil spending8,07516,89810,04013,28836,548
Number of Students29839754986

Cochise County Elections Results

PRESIDENTIAL ELECTORS
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
TRUMP, PENCEREP28092
CLINTON, KAINEDEM17450
JOHNSON, WELDLBT2394
STEIN, BARAKAGRN993
Total Votes48929
U.S. SENATOR
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
MCCAIN, JOHNREP27636
KIRKPATRICK, ANNDEM17642
SWING, GARYGRN3163
Total Votes48441
U.S. REPRESENTATIVE IN CD 2
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
MCSALLY, MARTHAREP33692
HEINZ, MATTDEM15718
Total Votes49410
STATE SENATOR DIST. 14
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
GRIFFIN, GAILREP29385
ALVAREZ, JAIMEDEM19364
Total Votes48749
STATE REPRESENTATIVE DIST. 14
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
JOHN, DREWREP26732
NUTT, BECKYREP26665
LINDSTROM, JASONDEM17592
HOLMES, MIKEDEM16616
Total Votes87605
CORPORATION COMMISSIONER
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
BURNS, ROBERT “BOB”REP29097
TOBIN, ANDYREP26542
DUNN, BOYDREP26386
MUNDELL, WILLIAM “BILL”DEM18413
CHABIN, TOMDEM17387
Total Votes117825
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS DISTRICT 1
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
CALL, PATREP16636
Total Votes16636
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS DISTRICT 2
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
ENGLISH, ANNDEM8638
MOOTS, DOMINIC “NICO”REP5802
Total Votes14440
BOARD OF SUPERVISORS DISTRICT 3
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
JUDD, PEGGYREP9937
PINAR, DAVIDDEM4484
Total Votes14421
COUNTY ATTORNEY
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
MCINTYRE, BRIAN M.REP30256
HOLZ, THOMAS C.IND15500
Total Votes45756
SHERIFF
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
DANNELS, MARK J.REP41597
Total Votes41597
COUNTY TREASURER
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
TRAYWICK, CATHERINE “CATHY”REP41562
Total Votes41562
COUNTY SCHOOL SUPERINTENDENT
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
CLAY, JACQUIREP29226
MIMS, JOY R.DEM18058
Total Votes47284
COUNTY RECORDER
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
STEVENS, DAVID W.REP27905
GARDNER, PETER B.DEM19606
Total Votes47511
COUNTY ASSESSOR
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
LEIENDECKER, PHILIP S.REP40850
Total Votes40850
JUSTICE OF THE ARIZONA SUPREME COURT – TIMMER
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
YESNON36467
NONON7106
Total Votes43573
JUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT DIV. 4
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
ELLEDGE, KARL D.NON40584
Total Votes40584
JUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT DIV. 5
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
CONLOGUE, JAMES L.NON40729
Total Votes40729
MAYOR CITY OF BISBEE
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
SMITH, DAVID M.NON1442
OERTLE, RONALDNON998
Total Votes2440
BOARD MEMBER APACHE ELEMENTARY USD #42
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
GROSSMAN, WILLIAM A.NON38
KRENTZ, FRANK R.NON29
Total Votes67
BOARD MEMBER BENSON USD #09
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
BERNAL, ROBERTNON2242
ROBERTS, ANN P.NON2192
BARNEY, BRETTNON2020
TAMEZ, PETE R.NON1423
Total Votes7877
BOARD MEMBER BISBEE USD #02
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
LITTRELL, ANN R.NON1581
POLANCO, PRIDONON1480
LOY, CAROL E.NON1323
HAMERS, ALICE R.NON1256
GIACOMINO, AUDREY “LUCHE”NON1217
Total Votes6857
BOARD MEMBER SIERRA VISTA USD #68
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
JOHNSON, MAUDELYNN “CONNIE”NON16115
Total Votes16115
BOARD MEMBER ST. DAVID USD #21
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
HAYNIE, BRADLEYNON1336
DAVIS, JAY T.NON1335
THOMAS, SHARONNON1027
Total Votes3698
BOARD MEMBER WILLCOX USD #13
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
OWEN, DWAYNE A.NON1575
HOPKINS, MARK L.NON1471
NOLAN, GUY P.NON1449
NOLAN, WILLIAM “BILL”NON1394
Total Votes5889
BOARD MEMBER WHETSTONE WATER DISTRICT
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
BARRETT, JAMES MIKENON229
PHELPS, DALE S.NON179
DOOLEY, JOE P.NON171
ENNIS, TONYNON153
Total Votes732
PROPOSITION 205
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
NONON27357
YESNON22120
Total Votes49477
PROPOSITION 206
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
YESNON26264
NONON22976
Total Votes49240
PROPOSITION 417 CITY OF TOMBSTONE
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
YESNON485
NONON310
Total Votes795
PROPOSITION 418 CITY OF BENSON
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
YESNON1166
NONON823
Total Votes1989
PROPOSITION 419 TOWN OF HUACHUCA CITY
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
YESNON332
NONON217
Total Votes549
QUESTION TOWN OF HUACHUCA CITY
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
YESNON391
NONON158
Total Votes549
PROPOSITION SAN SIMON USD #18
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
NONON176
YESNON145
Total Votes321
PROPOSITION WILLCOX USD #13
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
NONON1234
YESNON1209
Total Votes2443
PROPOSITION SIERRA VISTA USD #68
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
YESNON11150
NONON9176
Total Votes20326
PROPOSITION NORTHERN COCHISE HOSPITAL DISTRICT
Candidate/QuestionPartyVotes
YESNON2175
NONON1904
Total Votes4079